Acabo de leer una noticia breve en Nature que me ha dejado altamente perplejo. Os la pego aquí:

Nature 421, 197 (2003); doi:10.1038/421197a

US officials urge biologists to vet publications for bioterror risk

ERIKA CHECK





[WASHINGTON] Biologists need to devise a better process for handling the publication of unclassified research that bioterrorists could use, senior US government officials said last week.

The warning came at a meeting of scientific leaders, national-security professionals and government aides at the National Academies of Science (NAS) on 9 January. Scientific and security groups organized the gathering in response to fears that life-science research could be misused by terrorists.

John Marburger, head of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP), said that the Bush administration believes that most research should be kept unclassified. But he said the administration is searching for ideas about how best to deal with unclassified, 'dual-use' research that seems to aid the cause of terrorists and other would-be makers of bioweapons.

"Society expects its government to take reasonable steps to reduce the risk of bioterrorism, and the question before us is the nature of those steps," Marburger said.

Many of the 200 senior scientists, publishers and officials at the meeting argued anxiously that scientists must be free to publish all unclassified work. But others acknowledged that the community needs to reassure the public and the government that it is acting responsibly — even if they seemed unsure what steps they should take. Editors of journals, including Nature, who attended the meeting said afterwards that they hoped to release a joint statement shortly.

Parney Albright, an OSTP official now on secondment to the newly formed Department of Homeland Security, said that biologists need to think harder about the peer-review process. "There's a trade-off between the risks and benefits of efficient and open publication of scientific research, and the community needs to understand that better," Albright said.

He reminded the meeting that public distress over several controversial papers in the past two years has led to calls for restraint or regulation. One example arose in February 2001, when Australian researchers showed that altering a mousepox protein enabled it to kill animals that had been vaccinated against the virus. Last June, medical researchers showed how a smallpox protein disables a key element of the human immune system. And last August, Eckard Wimmer and colleagues at the University of New York at Stony Brook published a method for synthesizing poliovirus from scratch.

Albright said these papers had inspired unease among politicians and the public. "The science community ought to come up with a process before the public demands the government do it for them, and that will be driven by the rate at which controversial papers hit the streets," Albright said.

Two of the researchers whose papers were mentioned said they were not sure how this process should work. But neither regretted publishing their studies.

Immunologist Ariella Rosengard of the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine said that she felt conflicted about publishing her work on smallpox proteins, in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences last June. But keeping such results locked up would only slow down the biodefence effort, she said. "I'm worried that if we eliminate our ability to freely express our research results, we will end up saying it's just not worth it," Rosengard said.

Journal editors said they could think of few examples of papers that they would absolutely refuse to publish for security reasons. But some have begun including security concerns as a factor in peer review.

For instance, reviewers at the American Society of Microbiology's (ASM) 11 journals can flag a paper that appears to involve a "misuse of microbiology", said Sam Kaplan, chair of the ASM's Publications Board. Editors then review the paper and decide whether to reject it for security reasons.

ASM editors reviewed two papers for security reasons last year, said Kaplan. One is still under review; the other will be published in March. He urged government participants in the meeting not to put new burdens on reviewers. "I hope you all will realize the fragility of this process," Kaplan said.

Some participants pointed out the difficulties of implementing any changes that the United States may wish for in the international world of science. Sam Kaplan noted that 15% of the ASM's editorial board members are from abroad — as are some 60% of papers submitted to the journals.

"Other countries are moving slower on this," said NAS president Bruce Alberts. "We're going to have to have some international effort here or we don't have anything." He plans to raise the matter at a meeting of academy presidents in Amsterdam next week.

# - Escrito por Fabrizio el 2003-01-21 a las 23:11


Referencias (TrackBacks)

URL de trackback de esta historia http://fbenedetti.blogalia.com//trackbacks/4943

Comentarios

1
De: Vendell Fecha: 2003-01-22 00:41

Por ahora los terroristas han recurrido a métodos relativamente toscos (pistolas, bombas, aviones...) pero eso no quita que los de la siguiente generación se aprovechen de artículos tipo "Virulence boost in homebrew anthrax" disponibles en revistas de acceso público. El secreto no es bueno para la ciencia, pero puede ser peor para la sociedad.



2
De: Brunhilda Fecha: 2003-05-28 19:57

Estoy contigo, Vendell. No obstante, desde el origen de la ciencia, quienes más se han beneficiado de sus aplicaciones han sido los adinerados. "Poderoso caballero..."



3
De: Adam Fecha: 2019-01-15 07:50

HP Printer Support
HP Computer Support
HP Laptop Support
HP Printer Customer Service
HP Printer Drivers
HP Printer Helpline
HP Printer Atlanta
HP Printer Baltimore MD
HP Printer Berkeley CA
HP Printer Boston
HP Printer Chicago
Dell Customer Service
Samsung Customer Service
Toshiba Customer Service
Panasonic Customer Service
Epson Customer Service
Sharp Customer Service
Printronix Customer Service
Lemark Customer Service
Canon Customer Service
HP Printer Repair Near Me
HP Printer Orange County
HP Printer Orlando
HP Printer Pasadena CA
HP Printer Phoenix
HP Printer Portland Oregon
HP Printer Raleigh NC
HP Printer Sacramento
HP Printer San Diego
HP Printer San Francisco
HP Printer San Jose
HP Printer Seattle
HP Printer St Louis MO
HP Printer Tulsa
HP Printer Vancouver WA
HP Printer Setup
HP Printer Harvey Norman
HP Sacnner Support
HP Support Phone Number
HP Printer Installation
The Customer Service Phone Number
About Us
Adt Customer Service
Air India Express Airlines Customer Service
Airasia India Customer Service
Airlines Customer Service
Alaska Airlines Customer Service
Allegiant Air Customer Service
Amazon Customer Service Number
Apple Customer Service Number
Atlas Air Customer Service
Att Business Customer Service Number
Att Customer Service Number
Att Email Customer Service
Bank Of America Customer Service Number
Banks Customer Service
Boost Mobile Customer Service Number
British Airways Customer Service Number
British Airways Executive Club Customer Service Number
British Airways Uk Customer Service Number
Cable Companies Customer Service
Car Rental Customer Service
Cathay Pacific Airlines Customer Service
Chase Customer Service Number
Citizens Bank Customer Service Number
Comcast Customer Service Number
Comcast Email Customer Service
Comcast Xfinity Home Security Systems Customer Service Number
Companies
Computer Customer Service
Consumer Service Customer Service
Contact Us
Delta Airlines Skymiles Customer Service Number
Delta Customer Service Number
Department Store Customer Service
Dish Network Customer Service Number
Ebay Customer Service Number
Email
Enterprise Rent A Car Customer Service Number
Envoy Air Customer Service
Equifax Customer Service Number
Etihad Airways Customer Service
Expedia Customer Service Number
Fedex Canada Customer Service Number
Fedex Customer Service Number
Fedex International Customer Service Number
Geico Customer Service Number
Godaddy Email Customer Service
Government Customer Service
Hertz Customer Service Number
Home Security
Hp Customer Service
Hulu Customer Service Number
Icloud Mail Customer Service
Incredimail Customer Service
Insurance Customer Service
Irs Customer Service Number
Jet Airways Customer Service
Jetblue Airlines Customer Service Number
Juno Email Customer Service
Kroger Customer Service Number
Lufthansa Airlines Customer Service
Macy Customer Service Number
Malaysia Airlines Customer Service
Medco Pharmacy Customer Service Number
Netflix Customer Service Number
Office 365 Email Customer Service
Outlook Email Customer Service
Paypal Customer Service Number
Pharmacy Customer Service
Phone Company Customer Service
Roadrunner Email Customer Service
Sbcglobal Email Customer Service
Shipping Customer Service
Shopping Customer Service
Singapore Airlines Customer Service
Skywest Airlines Customer Service
Spicejet Airlines Customer Service
Spirit Airline Customer Service
Sprint Customer Service Number
Store
Straight Talk Customer Service Number
Supermarket Customer Service
T Mobile Customer Service Number
Tech
Thai Airways Customer Service
Time Warner Cable Customer Service Number
Trujet Airlines Customer Service
Turkish Airlines Customer Service
Uber Customer Service Number
United Airlines Customer Service Number
Ups Customer Service Number
Ups Freight Customer Service Number
Ups Mail Innovations Customer Service Number
Ups Uk Customer Service Number
Verizon Customer Service Number
Verizon Email Customer Service
Virgin America Customer Service Number
Visa Customer Service Number
Vivint Customer Service
Wells Fargo Customer Service Number
Xfinity Email Customer Service
Yahoo Customer Service Number
Yahoo Email Customer Service
Zoho Mail Customer Service
Dell Customer Service
Samsung Customer Service
Toshiba Customer Service
Panasonic Customer Service
Epson Customer Service
Sharp Customer Service
Printronix Customer Service
Lemark Customer Service
Canon Customer Service
Printer Support
Apple Wireless Printer Support
Brother Printer Support
Canon Printer Support
Contact Printer Support
Dell Printer Support
Epson Printer Support
HP Printer Support
Kodak Printer Support
Konica Minolta Printer Support
Kyocera Printer Support
Lanier Printer Support
Lexmark Printer Support
OKI Printer Support
Panasonic Printer Support
Ricoh Printer Support
Samsung Printer Support
Sharp Printer Support
Toshiba Printer Support
Xerox Printer Support
Google Chrome Customer Service
Mozilla Firefox Customer Service
Opera Mini Customer Service
Safari Customer Service
Internet Explorer Customer Service
Seamonkey Customer Service
Microsoft Edge Customer Service
Netscape Browser Customer Service
UC Browser Customer Service
Slimjet Browser Customer Service
Home Security Customer Service



Nombre
Correo-e
URL
Dirección IP: 107.23.129.77 (de5096f0e9)
Comentario
¿Cuánto es: diez mil + uno?

Ver historias anteriores